You are currently viewing Collins Barrow Tax Flash: Public pressure results in Finance re-examining proposed tax changes – Part 1 of 4

Collins Barrow Tax Flash: Public pressure results in Finance re-examining proposed tax changes – Part 1 of 4

On October 16, 2017, the Department of Finance (“Finance”) released changes (“announcement”) to the tax proposals previously announced in July 2017 (see CBT’s summary here). Today’s updates focused on the lifetime capital gains exemption and income sprinkling. A summary of the updates is as follows:

  1. Lifetime Capital Gains Exemption (“LCGE”)

Tax planning strategies designed to multiply access to the LCGE available to reduce the personal tax on a capital gain arising on the sale of qualifying property including private company shares were targeted in the tax proposals. 

The proposed measures would disallow the LCGE to minor shareholders (under 18 years of age) and inactive adult shareholders. In addition, the restriction applied towards any capital gains attributable to periods where a trust held the shares (with some limited exceptions).

In today’s announcement, Finance stated, “the Government will not be moving forward with the measures that would limit access to the Lifetime Capital Gains Exemption”. Further details from Finance as to how access to the LCGE will be maintained in relation to the other proposed measures (such as income sprinkling rules) were not provided.

  1. Income Sprinkling  

The Government is concerned that high income individuals are using private corporations to lower their personal income tax by shifting income to related individuals in lower tax brackets. Under the proposed measures, both the types of persons who are subject to the rules and the types of income would be expanded.

Throughout the consultation period, Finance received feedback on the complexity of the proposed measures and potential unintended consequences.  In particular, many respondents commented on the lack of certainty around the “reasonableness test” in the proposals.

Today’s announcement confirmed that Finance would continue with their proposals to terminate the shifting of income to related individuals in lower tax brackets. However, Finance will provide greater certainty surrounding the “reasonableness test” and will work to reduce the compliance burden with respect to establishing the contributions of related persons to better target the proposed rules and address concerns of double taxation.

The revised draft legislation for income sprinkling is expected to be released later this fall.

There were no updates related to other measures in the tax proposals – conversion of income into capital gains and holding of passive investments in a private corporation. Further updates from Finance on the tax proposals will occur throughout the week.

Reduction to Federal Small Business Tax Rate

Finance announced a reduction in the Federal small business tax rate. Currently, the Federal small business tax rate is 10.5%. As part of the Government’s commitment to reduce tax rates (a legacy item from the predecessor Government recommitted by the current Government), Finance has proposed to reduce the small business tax rate incrementally over two years. The Government will reduce the small business tax rate to 10% effective January 1, 2018, and to 9% effective January 1, 2019. The small business tax rate applies to the first $500,000 of active business income earned by a Canadian Controlled Private Corporation (“CCPC”). When fully implemented, the reduction in these tax rates will bring $7,500 in annual tax savings to qualifying CCPCs.